The element arsenic is known for its toxicity in its elemental form and in both oxidation states As(III) and As(V). Arsenic in natural water systems exists in both organic [e.g., arsanilic acid NH2PhAs(O)(OH)2] and inorganic [arsenite (AsO33-, As(III)), arsenate (AsO43-, As(V)] forms, whereby the inorganic anions are the more common and dangerous forms which are the reason for increasing water contamination today. In our study, we synthesized, crystallized, and measured high-resolution X-ray diffraction data sets of several arsenic oxides and arsenic ylides. We used complementary bonding analysis based on quantum crystallography and based on computational chemistry to understand the nature of chemical bonding within such compounds, with a focus on the role of the As atom, e.g. in terms of its increased atomic polarizability.
In addition, we used the same chemical bonding descriptors to explore intermolecular bonding between As(III) as well as As(V) and their respective environments. As(III) species can act ambivalently as Lewis acids or bases since they possess a lone pair unlike As(V) species which can only act as Lewis acids. However, As filters have so far only been constructed around the assumption that As acts as Lewis acid, although As(III) compounds are the more toxic ones. Hence, here we compare the dualistic intermolecular interaction modes of As(III) compounds to those in As(V) species to facilitate work on As(III) filters for freshwater.
The high toxicity of As compounds is an indicator for their strong interactions with biological environments. Therefore, arsenic has long been used therapeutically as well. Here, we focus on the most controversial historic arsenic-based drug atoxyl (Fig. 1) to explore its characteristics using complementary bonding analysis as well. Finally, we compare it with the previously studied toxic systems to better understand the role of the As atom, even if it is not involved in any intermolecular interactions.